_thumbnail_id: Array
author: Array
_author: Array
article_modules: Array
_article_modules: Array
modules_0_title: Array
_modules_0_title: Array
modules_0_content: Array
_modules_0_content: Array
modules: Array
_modules: Array
modules_2_download_box_download_box_title: Array
_modules_2_download_box_download_box_title: Array
modules_2_download_box_download_box_button_text: Array
_modules_2_download_box_download_box_button_text: Array
modules_2_download_box_download_box_button_url: Array
_modules_2_download_box_download_box_button_url: Array
modules_1_title: Array
_modules_1_title: Array
modules_1_content: Array
_modules_1_content: Array
modules_1_download_box_download_box_title: Array
_modules_1_download_box_download_box_title: Array
modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_text: Array
_modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_text: Array
modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_type: Array
_modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_type: Array
modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_url: Array
_modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_url: Array
modules_1_download_box: Array
_modules_1_download_box: Array
modules_2_quote_author: Array
_modules_2_quote_author: Array
modules_2_enable_tweet: Array
_modules_2_enable_tweet: Array
modules_2_quote: Array
_modules_2_quote: Array
modules_3_title: Array
_modules_3_title: Array
modules_3_content: Array
_modules_3_content: Array
modules_4_title: Array
_modules_4_title: Array
modules_4_content: Array
_modules_4_content: Array
modules_5_background_image: Array
_modules_5_background_image: Array
modules_5_video_title: Array
_modules_5_video_title: Array
modules_5_video_thumbnail_url: Array
_modules_5_video_thumbnail_url: Array
modules_5_video_url: Array
_modules_5_video_url: Array
modules_5_video_duration: Array
_modules_5_video_duration: Array
modules_5_video_description: Array
_modules_5_video_description: Array
modules_5_video_embed_code: Array
_modules_5_video_embed_code: Array
modules_6_title: Array
_modules_6_title: Array
modules_6_content: Array
_modules_6_content: Array
modules_5_image_caption: Array
_modules_5_image_caption: Array
_yoast_wpseo_content_score: Array
article_modules_0_title: Array
_article_modules_0_title: Array
article_modules_0_content: Array
_article_modules_0_content: Array
article_modules_1_download_box_download_box_title: Array
_article_modules_1_download_box_download_box_title: Array
article_modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_text: Array
_article_modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_text: Array
article_modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_type: Array
_article_modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_type: Array
article_modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_url: Array
_article_modules_1_download_box_download_box_button_url: Array
_yoast_wpseo_primary_category: Array
_wp_old_slug: Array
article_modules_1_quote_author: Array
_article_modules_1_quote_author: Array
article_modules_1_enable_tweet: Array
_article_modules_1_enable_tweet: Array
article_modules_1_quote: Array
_article_modules_1_quote: Array
article_modules_2_title: Array
_article_modules_2_title: Array
article_modules_2_content: Array
_article_modules_2_content: Array
modules_0_module_title: Array
_modules_0_module_title: Array
modules_0_background_color: Array
_modules_0_background_color: Array
modules_0_module_type: Array
_modules_0_module_type: Array
modules_0_filter_posts_by_taxonomy: Array
_modules_0_filter_posts_by_taxonomy: Array
modules_0_filter_posts_by_tags: Array
_modules_0_filter_posts_by_tags: Array
modules_0_link_text: Array
_modules_0_link_text: Array
modules_0_link_url: Array
_modules_0_link_url: Array
_dp_original: Array
_edit_lock: Array
_edit_last: Array
_yoast_wpseo_title: Array
_yoast_wpseo_metadesc: Array
page_summary: Array
_page_summary: Array
modules_1_text: Array
_modules_1_text: Array
modules_2_module_title: Array
_modules_2_module_title: Array
modules_2_background_color: Array
_modules_2_background_color: Array
modules_2_column_ratio: Array
_modules_2_column_ratio: Array
modules_2_editor_content_left: Array
_modules_2_editor_content_left: Array
modules_2_button_text_right: Array
_modules_2_button_text_right: Array
modules_2_button_type_right: Array
_modules_2_button_type_right: Array
modules_2_button_url_local_right: Array
_modules_2_button_url_local_right: Array
article_primary_tag: Array
_article_primary_tag: Array
Is the US post-crisis recovery now complete?

Is the US post-crisis recovery now complete?

Jackie Bowie Weekly bulletin June 2018

A week of important meetings – and yet our eyes were not on Singapore, but firmly on the Fed. The economic growth picture in the US just seems to get better and better, making economists and market participants even more nervous of when the turn (recession) will come, and how painful it will be.

At a glance, the US economy appears to be in a perfect sweet spot: capital expenditure is increasing; consumer confidence is high (note the retail sales numbers this week); inflation is under control and forecast to stay reasonably low. It is difficult to envision what exactly will catch us out. However, turn to the employment figures and the cracks start to show. The labour market is extremely tight, with May’s unemployment rate of 3.8% representing an 18 year low and – crucially – the second month in a row for which there have been more job openings than people registered as looking for work. This means that ‘quits’ should increase, and wage growth will not be far behind. Given its current low level, particularly when compared to previous late cycle statistics, this could lead to a significant shock. As companies look ahead to 2019, labour costs are forecast to be in their top 3 concerns.

The Fed of course raised rates by the predicted 0.25% at the meeting, and added a fourth dot to their projection for 2018; indicating no change to the total number of rate rises but altering the distribution of when they will occur between now and 2020. Market expectations are under-shooting the Fed’s own “Dots” by as much as 0.50% through 2019 and 0.75% to the end of 2020.

The press conference contained a change in language used to reference growth – now ‘solid’ rather than ‘moderate’ – and a small uptick in growth forecasts to 2.8% for 2018 (which looks likely to be beaten). More telling was the absence of a paragraph contained in previous statements, which had stated that ‘the federal funds rate is likely to remain, for some time, below levels that are expected to prevail in the longer run’. It is difficult to interpret what this omission means, but my guess is that the normalisation of monetary policy might need to pivot towards a more hawkish position in order to reign in growth (and higher inflation) should the economy continue to demonstrate the strength it has in recent months.

The Fed have, in my view, done a remarkable job of guiding the markets through their normalisation activity, and the use of the ‘dot plot’ to consistently provide forward guidance has definitely helped their credibility. However, I would question whether such transparency has the same benefits when the monetary cycle has to turn the other way. If the dot plot starts to show an uptick in future rates, would the market take that to mean the Fed was predicting a slowdown or recession? And would this then become a self-fulfilling prophecy? With this in mind, we may have the reason for Powell announcing that from January next year the Fed will hold a press conference after every meeting, rather than just at the end of each quarter). It will give the Fed the chance to make more frequent changes (so far, since 2011 all movements in rates have happened at meetings which were followed by a press statement) and react to the economic data flow more nimbly; at the same time weaning the market off the forward guidance on which it has become so reliant.

Emerging markets, and their currencies in particular, have certainly been the ones who have suffered in the Fed’s successful normalisation and the strengthening USD – basically bad news for all risk assets. Spillover effects from US monetary policy are nothing new, but on this occasion the threat of a bull run by the USD has prompted the Governor of the Reserve Bank of India, Urjit Patel, to take the deeply unusual step of calling on the Fed to slow down. His argument is that when the Fed started the process of shrinking its balance sheet, President Trump’s tax cuts were not yet on the horizon. Now that the scale of the US fiscal deficit is known (having already absorbed foreign savings, it will now require bond issuance to the tune of $1.8 trillion), the Fed should adjust its balance sheet management to limit the effects of lower USD liquidity. The mechanics of this argument are correct – but it is hard not to point out that the Fed’s role is to achieve its domestic objectives, not to prioritise emerging market pain relief.

We would expect some calm to return to emerging markets when forward looking markets have fully reflected the change in US policy – fiscal and monetary. And before last week’s Fed meeting it was conceivable that we were getting close to that point. However, recent hawkishness this week suggests there might be more pain to come.

There is also a much more important question to ask. It is obviously tempting to call the end of the post-crisis recovery and close the door on an extremely difficult period. But the real question is not whether the last crisis is over – it is how the next one will begin. For those of us planning to stay in the markets, just as useful than the Fed’s pronouncements might be the words of Yogi Berra: “it ain’t over until it’s over”.


Recent Insights

Currency seesaw
Chris Towner Weekly bulletin October 2019
Privatisation opportunities in sub-Saharan Africa
Lionel Kruger Project Finance & Infrastructure October 2019

Contact us

If you need hedging or debt advice or would like to speak about how we could help your business, please get in touch.